Rhian Sheehan
Wed 25 Mar 2009

Rhian Sheehan – Standing In Silence
4/10
It is problematic when listening to a CD through a computer when you can hear the computer’s fan better than the music, even when the volume is turned way up. Sheehan’s album reminds of a time when everything took a long time; scribbling words on a page, making music, getting anywhere; communicating. Through its evocative and emotive answering machines-on-parade style bleeps and blips, Parts 01 – 14 (such is the way the songs are titled) are laconic and technologically designed to mirror the stark chemical nature of our modern world. Sheehan sounds like he is expressing the idea of loneliness and frustration in man-made nature through man-made music. His vocal-less slow-moving sketchy techno-dub coasts elegantly through waters of lush blues and idyllic greens like a blue whale on its own course. It’s the biggest thing out there and no one can mess with it; only marvel at its beauty. It’s when the music fades out of your consciousness because its songs are impersonally and solely instrumental orchestrated music that it loses its majestic emotion-swelling grandeur and becomes more like densely layered and thoughtfully constructed elevator music (Parts 4 and 7). Other times it reeks of overly dramatic emotion-wrenching classical music (Parts 8 and 10). Sheehan uses field recordings from his travels around Asia, as well as found objects that he manipulated in his attic studio. Knowledge of this makes the recordings feel more resonant and relevant, for without understanding the production history of Silence it sounds electronically manufactured; the lone insight of a man who maybe distances himself from society, when in fact this is not the case at all. Sheehan is trying to encourage positive change with Standing In Silence, however a tedious and oft-dreary listen it may be. However he should be applauded for releasing this album with a week-long gallery exhibition at the Moving Images Centre (K Rd, Auckland). With the aid of Greenpeace and artist friends Sheehan devised an exhibition where the patron listens to the album through headphones while absorbing other visual arts – a true state of standing in silence. The exhibition took place in late February and showed films of cultures in the midst of change (India, Japan, China), and illustrated industrialisation’s effect on the environment, urban development and our relationship to nature. These films are to be used in upcoming live performances by Sheehan. Buy this album if you like abstract dub/instrumental electronic/field recordings, or if only to help fund Greenpeace’s Climate Change action, for a percentage of profits from album sales go directly to Greenpeace.
Sarah
Posted by Sarah Gooding under Album, Reviews
[7] Comments









April 10th, 2009 at 4:34 pm
“Buy this album if you like abstract dub”???
For a more intellectual analysis of this fantastic album check out the US Silent Ballet review:
http://thesilentballet.com/dnn/Reviews/tabid/54/ctl/Details/mid/438/ItemID/2265/Default.aspx
April 10th, 2009 at 4:50 pm
I just wasted 2 minutes of my life reading this “tedious and oft-dreary” review by someone who couldn’t be bothered putting the CD in an actual stereo system for a first listen.
You’d seriously go to all the trouble to write a review of an ambient album based on what you hear through your crummy computer speakers?
I couldn’t disagree with this review more.
April 10th, 2009 at 5:34 pm
Linda, you have an opinion, Sarah has an opinion.
Are you still living in the ’90s? Most of the stereos nowadays have worse sound than high quality computer speakers. You call them “crummy”, you’d do better just saying you disagree with the review.
April 10th, 2009 at 5:35 pm
You’d seriously attempt a criticism like that when you have no idea what my speakers are like? That’s hilarious. For your information I have very good quality computer speakers.
April 11th, 2009 at 12:09 pm
Uh oh. Um, it’s getting a bit bitchy here.
Wouldn’t Nick and Sarah be better defending their ‘opinions’, rather than the quality of their playback facilities?
Or even simply staying out of the comments altogether?
The above review is a little odd. There’s actually some valid observations and genuine insight, but the message got lost in amongst something about a whale, some mumbling about the music sounding exactly how it does – only with negative connotations for tabloid effect, and then a touch of regurgitated press release stuff? Hmm.
Nick, you’d do better just saying ‘people have opinions’ – like wow man.
For the record, I too disagree with the review.
Rhian’s album, in MY opinion, is a textural moodscape, rich with depth and detail, revealing itself over repeat listens.
The rating of 4/10 is misleading.
April 13th, 2009 at 11:00 am
Though I think the review is obviously written by someone who doesn’t generally listen to this kind of music, I think the rating is actually quite fair… I’d probably give it 5 or 6/10, as it’s crafted very well. The problem for me is its relevance… ‘Standing in Silence’ feels like a copy of a copy of a copy – people like William Basinski, Johan Johaanson, Hildur Gudnadottir all spring to mind as the more obvious reference points from the last few years. The highlight for me was a very strange guitar lead somewhere in the middle of the album, the (sadly, unintentional) humour breaking the “overly dramatic emotion-wrenching classical music”.
Don’t get me started on the accompanying visual concepts.
April 13th, 2009 at 6:22 pm
Andrea, I agree with you. 4/10 is very misleading. All the other reviews I’ve read about this album have been very positive. (maybe they all listened through a decent sound system eh?)
I’d give it 9/10. Its an stunning album, and I think it was a very brave one to release given that it sounds almost nothing like his previous albums. Interesting that the review didn’t touch on this I thought.
I guess you cant please everyone though eh? I wonder what names Danial would have made comparisons to if Sheehan had just gone and released another album with electronic beats and pads etc. The list would have been far longer I’m sure.
In the context of the NZ scene this is a very original album, and I’m surprised that you would pigeonhole it Danial. I have Johan Johaanson’s new album, and it pales in comparison to Standing in Silence in scope and concept by a long shot.
This really is an album you need to spend time with with the lights down low and a nice bottle of wine. It really takes me away to a beautiful place.
K